Issues with Shell Brittleness During Hard Gelatin Capsule Production

Addressing Issues with Shell Brittleness During Hard Gelatin Capsule Production

Context

In the production of hard gelatin capsules, achieving the right balance between flexibility and brittleness of the capsule shell is essential for maintaining capsule integrity during handling, storage, and transportation. Excessive brittleness can lead to cracked or broken capsules, resulting in product defects, wastage, and compromised quality. This issue can be particularly problematic during the later stages of capsule production and storage, where environmental conditions such as humidity, temperature, and the encapsulation process itself can influence the strength and flexibility of the capsule

shell. Ensuring that capsules are durable without becoming too brittle is key to maintaining product quality and minimizing losses.

Root Causes

Excessive Moisture Loss: During the capsule drying process, if the capsules lose too much moisture, they can become too brittle. Gelatin capsules need to retain a certain level of moisture to maintain flexibility and prevent cracking.
Incorrect Gelatin Composition: The ratio of gelatin to plasticizers and other excipients plays a critical role in determining the capsule’s flexibility. Insufficient plasticizer content or the use of low-quality gelatin can result in shells that are too brittle.
Improper Drying Conditions: Overdrying capsules or exposing them to high temperatures or low humidity can lead to excessive moisture loss, causing the capsules to become fragile and prone to breakage.
Environmental Factors: Fluctuations in temperature and humidity during capsule production, storage, and transportation can contribute to brittleness. High temperatures can accelerate drying, while low humidity can cause rapid moisture loss, both of which can negatively affect the capsule’s physical properties.
Over-processing: Excessive processing during the manufacturing stages, such as over-compression or prolonged heating, can alter the physical properties of the gelatin and lead to shell brittleness.

Pharma Tip: Inadequate Studies for Drug-Excipient Interaction During Development

Solutions

1. Optimizing Moisture Content in Gelatin Capsules

To prevent brittleness, it is essential to maintain the proper moisture content in gelatin capsules during the drying process. The target moisture content should be between 13% and 16%, depending on the formulation and environmental conditions. Moisture-controlled drying chambers should be used to maintain consistent humidity and temperature during the drying process. Regular monitoring of moisture levels during production can help avoid excessive moisture loss, ensuring that capsules retain adequate flexibility.

2. Adjusting Gelatin Composition

Optimizing the gelatin composition is critical to achieving the right balance between flexibility and brittleness. Increasing the ratio of plasticizers such as glycerin or sorbitol can improve the flexibility of the gelatin shell. Plasticizers help reduce the brittleness of the capsule by allowing the gelatin to retain its elasticity. Using higher-quality gelatin with better strength properties can also contribute to improved capsule durability. The formulation should be carefully tested to achieve the right properties for the specific capsule application.

3. Implementing Controlled Drying Processes

To avoid excessive brittleness, it is important to control the drying process closely. Slow and controlled drying methods should be employed to ensure that the capsules do not lose moisture too quickly. The drying temperature should be kept within a specific range to prevent overheating, which can damage the gelatin structure. Automated systems that monitor and control the drying temperature, humidity, and airflow can help ensure that the drying process is gradual and uniform, resulting in a flexible capsule shell that is not too brittle.

Pharma Tip: Difficulty in preventing contamination of capsule packs during sealing.

4. Environmental Control During Storage

Environmental conditions, such as temperature and humidity, should be carefully controlled during the storage and transportation of capsules to prevent brittleness. Capsules should be stored in climate-controlled environments that maintain a consistent temperature and humidity level. Humidity levels should be kept within the optimal range to prevent moisture loss, and temperature fluctuations should be minimized to reduce the risk of cracking due to sudden changes in capsule structure. Capsules should also be stored in sealed containers to prevent exposure to air and moisture, which can affect their physical properties.

5. Use of Coatings or Treatments

To further reduce brittleness, the use of protective coatings can be considered. Soft gelatin coatings or enteric coatings can be applied to protect the capsule shell from environmental stresses and improve its mechanical strength. These coatings can provide an additional layer of protection against cracking and ensure that the capsules maintain their integrity during handling and storage.

6. Preventing Over-Processing During Manufacturing

To avoid brittleness, it is important to prevent over-processing of the capsules during manufacturing. Care should be taken to avoid excessive compression, prolonged heating, or over-drying, as these processes can weaken the gelatin structure and lead to brittleness. Optimization of machine settings, such as pressure, speed, and temperature, should be conducted to ensure that the capsules are not subjected to conditions that could lead to unwanted physical changes.

7. Quality Control and Testing

Implementing rigorous quality control tests is critical to detect brittleness early in the manufacturing process. Visual inspection of the capsules for cracks or breaks should be conducted throughout production. Additionally, mechanical strength tests such as crushing tests or bending tests can be used to evaluate the flexibility and durability of the capsules. Capsules that fail these tests should be removed from the production line to prevent defective products from reaching the market.

Pharma Tip: Difficulty in implementing real-time data monitoring systems for quality checks.

Regulatory Considerations

Regulatory agencies such as the FDA, EMA, and USP have established guidelines for ensuring that pharmaceutical products, including capsules, meet strict quality standards. USP <711> Dissolution Testing and USP <2040> Uniformity of Dosage Units require that capsules be free from defects such as cracks or breaks that could affect their performance. Manufacturers must demonstrate that their capsules meet cGMP guidelines and pass necessary strength and integrity tests to ensure that they maintain their functionality during handling, storage, and use.

Case Study

Case Study: Improving Shell Brittleness in Hard Gelatin Capsule Production

A pharmaceutical company producing hard gelatin capsules for an over-the-counter product faced challenges with capsule brittleness, leading to high rejection rates. The company implemented improvements by adjusting the gelatin formulation, increasing the plasticizer content to enhance flexibility. Additionally, they optimized the drying process by implementing temperature-controlled drying chambers that reduced the rate of moisture loss. As a result, capsule brittleness was significantly reduced, leading to fewer defects and a more reliable product. The company also instituted stricter quality control checks and increased the frequency of mechanical strength testing, further improving the durability of the final product.